Culture

Abortion supporters unhappy with pro-life billboards in Ireland

One of the pro-life billboards created by Life Institute and Youth Defence.

While abortion is illegal in Ireland, except for in circumstances in which there is a substantial risk to the life of the mother, there is the constant threat of abortion laws become less and less restrictive. Therefore, pro-life groups work overtime to ensure that this doesn’t happen, using large campaigns and holding rallies to remind everyone what abortion really is. Meanwhile, the pro-abortion group Choice Ireland is attacking a new ad campaign, created by the pro-life groups Life Institute and Youth Defence, which depicts abortion as an act that tears lives apart. Choice Ireland is claiming that the ads misrepresent Life Institute’s mission, and that the billboards are offensive to women. Choice Ireland spokesperson Stephanie Lord says on the group’s website:

Choice Ireland have received a number of angry and offended emails about these billboards, which proclaim that abortion tears a woman’s life apart. Some of the emails are from women who have had abortions themselves and who object to the message the billboards convey. These billboards do not speak for them (…)If (Life Institute’s) concern for women was genuine they would not spend the large costs of these billboards on trying to make women feel bad about the choices they have made.

But Life Institute isn’t out to make women who have had abortions feel guilty; they’re out to stop other women from having abortions in the first place. The ads simply state that there are better options than abortion and that abortion destroys not only the life of the child, but that of the mother as well. The idea for the advertising campaign, which includes 600 billboards, and ads on Facebook and YouTube, was actually sparked by a conversation with a real-life woman who had an abortion. As reported at TheLifeInstitute.net, Niamh Uí Bhriain of Life Institute says:

Last year I had a very moving conversation with an Irish woman who underwent an abortion while living in Britain years before. She told me that she felt her life was torn apart by the abortion, and that her baby’s life was torn apart as well. I thought it was a powerful description of the reality of abortion, which is all too often glossed over in the debate on the issue.

And she’s right. Abortion literally tears a child apart, and that’s what many pro-life groups focus on. However, there is great debate on the long-term emotional side effects of abortion on women. Pro-abortion groups would have us all believe that women simply walk away from abortions feeling mostly relieved. However, numerous studies have shown that abortion causes depression, guilt, stress, emotional deadening, rage, and difficulty maintaining relationships. Known as post-abortion syndrome, these psychological effects are real and lifelong, and Life Institute’s new ad campaign exposes that. Choice Ireland’s outrage is more about the fact that they want to keep this information hidden than it is about their concern that women may be offended.

In Ireland’s fight to keep abortion illegal, campaigns like this are as necessary as they are in the U.S., where abortion is legal at any time for any reason. As Rebecca Roughneen of Youth Defence explains in the Life Institute post regarding the billboards:

This campaign also aims to wake up the pro-life majority and urge them to make their voice heard before abortion is legalised by a wealthy and powerful elite who want, at all costs, to avoid consulting the people. The Irish people know that we can do better for mothers and babies than the medieval solution of abortion. The UN has shown that Ireland, without abortion, is the safest place in the world for a mother to have a baby. Let’s keep it that way.

Live Action on Facebook
  • SK

    Interesting  how you deleted the part of Choice Ireland’s statement which quoted research showing 87% of women who had abortions believed it was the right decision.

    • Kate

      Interesting because they quoted research from the Crisis Pregnancy Agency, which strongly PROMOTES abortion? Yes – I would say that is an interesting statistic… maybe someone should write a post about how the CPA claims that “87% of women who had abortions believed it was the right decision” because they want more women to have abortions…. hmmm…

      • AD

        How does the Crisis Pregnancy Programme promote abortion? Why on earth would they want more women to have abortions? I’d really love to hear your answers to these questions, with some evidence if possible. The Crisis Pregnancy Programme (formerly Crisis Pregnancy Agency) is a state programme with the aims of preventing and responding to crisis pregancy. They provide information on sexuality, contraception and crisis pregnancy support.  The crisis pregnancy support agencies they include in their directory vary from 2 option counselling (adoption and continuing with the pregnancy only) and 3 option counselling (adoption, pregnancy and information on travelling abroad for abortion).  If you’re suggesting that acknowledging a pregnant woman’s legal right to information about abortion in Ireland is tantamount to supporting abortion, that’s pretty extreme. Hopefully you’ve some other reason for stating that though.

    • Evamarcum54

      that is disgusting. good for them sickoos!

  • Ab

    Its pro-choice not pro-abortion. Twisting ideas to suit your argument simply shows the weakness of it. Pro-choice does not force abortions on those who do not want it while pro-life forces a decision on women during one of the most emotional times of their life. Pro-choice is a CHOICE which every woman should be free to make with regards to their body and their lives. This campaign enforces the negative stigma in Ireland and sets Ireland back years. It is disturbing that this level of obvious propaganda is allowed in this day and age.

    • http://twitter.com/CalFreiburger Calvin Freiburger

      You can’t pretend to oppose “twisting ideas to suit your argument” when you do the exact same thing – you disingenuously describe it as a question women making decisions “with regards to their body and their lives,” when the whole reason abortion is controversial is because it destroys SOMEONE ELSE’S body and life.

      • Evamarcum54

        i like that but i also belive once you get pregnant which i am! it is not just YOUR body anymore it is the childs as well!

    • Kate

      I am pro-life, but I don’t mind when people call me anti-abortion… because that’s what I am… against abortion. I’m additionally pro-life and believe that every human person has a right to life, including the unborn, but also the born. Why do pro-choicers get all crazy when people call them pro-abortion??? That’s what ye are. 

      And calm down… Ireland has had a protection for the unborn in their Constitution for years… how can you say this billboard campaign “puts Ireland back years”? Also – to claim that it enforces “the negative stigma in Ireland”… if anything, I’m sure it’s given women the opportunity to heal from the hurt of losing their children and has encouraged others to choose life for their children. 

      Lastly – when did freedom of speech become “propaganda”? Oh that’s right… Ireland doesn’t believe in freedom of speech, do they? Or maybe only the freedom of speech that you “Ab” approve of? 

    • Guest

      Yeah, especially because that ultrasound picture on the billboard is way past the point when most abortions happen. At least women in Ireland are usually able to get to other European countries to obtain an abortion. And from what I understand, they do have exceptions for rape, incest, fetal abnormalities, and health of the woman. 

    • Heather Williams

      The vast majority of our laws are pro-life. Our government doesn’t give you the “choice” to kill your spouse, children or coworkers simply because they’re not convenient. They call it murder when you kill on purpose, manslaughter when it’s not. 

      Why don’t they call killing your spouse “pro-choice”? It’s not like they’re forcing you to kill him/her. You can keep them alive if you want, allow them to depend on you. It’s practically a TRAGEDY that our country is so pr0-life when it comes to co-dependent spouses and children, not to mention bosses. They’re practically forcing you to take care of something you don’t want to take care of. 

      If killing something that can protest and protect itself is wrong, then what is killing something that cannot protest? That’s somehow right? Give me a break dude. You’re seriously twisted in the head. 

    • Vlad777

      No actually Ab, you folks changed the debate when you perverted the meaning of work choice to reflect legalized baby killing.  I love your bumper stickers, “Pro-Family, Pro-Choice.  How is killing your own baby “choice”?  Talk about twisting words.  The pro-abortion proponents have perfected the art of linguistic torture

    • http://www.facebook.com/ashley.whalen.92 Ashley Whalen

      thats like saying its a good choice to murder  your neighbor because you simply cant deal with them at this point in your life(18 days after conception theres a heart beat,women dont usually find out they are prego till 6 weeks after conception).Also proabortion and pro choice are the same becasue if a woman chooses to get an abortion then you are now pro-abortion.

    • Earnesttt

      Actually its a child, not a choice!

    • maura mc c

      Pro-Choice is not an honest term as the unborn child gets no choice in the ending of its life. Surely the right to life should be the most basic of all rights.

  • Evamarcum54

    im glad it upsets abortion supporters it just means we are getting to them. they know abortion  is wrong they just dont have the guts to stand up and say it so let them fade into the backround.

    • Callie

      I would call them pro-abortion rather than pro-choice because I personally know (shockingly) several women who had an abortion against their wishes. A friend got an abortion to prevent getting kicked out of her mothers house, a different friend had a boyfriend that said he would leave her if she didn’t get an abortion. The worst story yet was when another friend rld me she went to the cliniccuz she didn’t know what to do, and she ended up getting an abortion because she said
      they didn’t give her options, they just ramrod her into out

      • Callie Maertz

        Point is: when abortion is legal for anyone for whatever reason, then it is sooo easy for everyone else to make the decision that the mother needs an abortion. I experienced some of that because I was 15 when I got pregnant. Thankfully I had some supporters and im stronger than many of these other girls that get pushed into having abortion s. But I just think abortion serves the selfish purposes of others rather than the mother. This whole “her body her choice” thing is mostly a lie.

  • Paulo Mendonça

    Wanna stop the criminalization of abortion on the world? So please give a LIKE on brazillian’s movement on facebook in favor of abortion’s legalization, it will only take 5 seconds.
    The link is: facebook.com/abortoeumdireito
    Obrigado, my friends!  

  • pc

    I had hoped that Ireland was no longer a place where discrimination and bigotry was accepted! I am horrified to think that i live in a country that allows such discrimatory propaganda as a means of communication. One woman’s experience does not reflect the experiences of thousands of others.