Opinion

More parents come forward with a wrongful birth suit, would have aborted their daughter

While Ariel and Deborah Levy – the parents who won a wrongful birth suit because their daughter has Down syndrome – were surely not the first parents to file a “we wish we could have aborted our living child” suit, their case could certainly be considered the most notorious. It garnered nationwide attention. One of the things many pro-lifers worried about was that this would set a dangerous precedent.

Now another couple is making headlines. A judge has given the parents the OK to move forward with their wrongful birth suit. Like the Levys, if they had known their daughter was disabled, they would have aborted her.

When did parents start believing that children are acceptable only if they are perfect? Apparently, there are people who believe that if their child is somehow “flawed,” he or she doesn’t deserve to live. Right now, these cases seem to be strictly about disabilities. But where is the line drawn? With prenatal testing becoming more and more advanced, what will happen when the baby has the wrong eye color? The wrong hair color? Babies are already aborted around the world for being born the wrong gender. What makes a certain baby’s life worth living, while another baby is deemed unfit for life?

One of the most abhorrent things about this case, and that of the Levys’, is that the parents are asking to be paid off because they have to raise their child. How many parents demand millions to compensate them for the hassle of raising their son or their daughter? What’s worse is that doing so in such a public manner means that the affected children will surely find out about it when they’re older. Imagine finding out that your parents demanded millions of dollars because they weren’t able to kill you.

The idea that a child is worthy of life only if he or she is acceptable to the parents is sad – and wrong. Part of being a parent is being willing to shoulder whatever burden is handed to you. What if the child is born perfectly healthy, but then is diagnosed with cancer? Is in a car accident and becomes paralyzed? By the logic behind these wrongful birth suits, the parents should be allowed to euthanize them then, because Heaven forbid they have to take care of a sick or disabled child. You don’t decide to become a parent, but add in the caveat that the child is deserving of life only if they meet your criteria. Just because a person is disabled, it does not mean that he doesn’t deserve to live, or that he isn’t deserving of your unconditional love.

It is, frankly, disgusting that there are parents out there who could look at their child, say “I would have aborted you,” and then demand a payoff. And what is scary is that the more parents win these wrongful birth suits, the more other parents will be encouraged to do the same. Worse, the attitude that disabled = defective will be furthered, and that finding out your unborn child is disabled means that he or she should be aborted.

Life comes in many different shapes and forms, and all of it is precious. Just because a child has Down syndrome, cystic fibrosis, or any other disability, it doesn’t mean that she doesn’t deserve to live.

Live Action on Facebook
  • Pingback: More Parents Come Forward with a Wrongful Birth Suit, Would Have Aborted Their Daughter | Live Action News & Opinion | A mí, háblame en Cristiano

  • http://rau.3littlefoxes.com/ LindaF

    NO child (or, in fact, no person) is perfect – we all have flaws.  A true parent loves them anyway.  All humans are perfect to their Heavenly Father.

  • Pingback: More Parents Come Forward with a Wrongful Birth Suit, Would Have Aborted Their Daughter | Foundation Life

  • jtliuzza

    The nazis had a phrase, “life not worthy of life.”  Global socialism, eugenics.  Hitler could have saved us all a lot of trouble what with that whole WWII mess.  If only he had known that the entire west was going to eventually come around to his way of thinking anyway he could have just sat around and waited.

    • Broken5glass

      Do you mind if I copy and paste this to my facebook page??

      • liveaction

        Actually, if you press the “Like” button, you should be able to add the article to your Facebook page as long as you add a comment with it. If that doesn’t work for you, yes, add the article on your Facebook however you can.

  • Xnavy8185

    When I was 24 years old, my mother told me that if she had known where an abortionist was that my brother Neil and I would not be living. I was born in 1961 when abortion was illegal and my brother Neil was born in 1959. It hurt that she said that to me, but I have forgiven her and miss her. She died of cancer in 2000, her cancer was brain cancer. She told me that her only child that was planned was my brother Billy. We were born all healthy.

  • falling321

    Too bad we can’t chose our parents…I’m sure this little girl would MUCH rather have loving parents than the creeps she was born to!

  • Guest

    The problem with condemning these lawsuits is that (a) without them, doctors would be free to lie to pregnant women if they feared that they would get an abortion and (b) as terrible as our health care system is in this country, parents do actually need a great deal of money to get the best possible care for a disabled child. 

    My state has outlawed wrongful birth suits, and because of this, if I ever decide to have a child, I plan to get prenatal care in a neighboring state.