International

Uruguay Senate Approves Abortion, Despite Popular Opposition

The Senate of Uruguay voted to accept an abortion compromise bill Wednesday, despite opposition from the majority of the Uruguayan people. Before the vote, senators used intimidation tactics to silence pro-life critics. If approved by the president, the bill to legalize first-trimester abortions will make Uruguay the first Latin American country other than communist Cuba to permit elective abortion.

A more radically pro-abortion version of the bill was previously passed by the Senate in December 2011. After many revisions, the lower Chamber of Deputies passed the legislation by a single-vote margin at the end of September. Now that the Senate has sealed its approval on the compromise bill, it will be sent to President José Mujica’s desk. Although he has promised to sign the bill, the executive office will face stringent opposition from the citizenry.

Personhood Education, a global outreach project of Personhood USA, commissioned the largest poll ever conducted on the issue of abortion in Uruguay – likely the largest poll ever conducted in Uruguay on any issue – which surveyed 118,264 households. A resounding 56.1% of respondents identified themselves as pro-life and in favor of protecting life before birth. Only 43.9% said that they supported the abortion legislation. This poll directly conflicts with a much smaller survey of only 800 people that inaccurately suggested that the majority of Uruguayans support abortion.

Protege La Vida is a grassroots pro-life group building a coalition to keep abortion out of Uruguay. Their rapidly growing Facebook page, which was created last week, had over 8,000 “likes” today. Thousands of citizens called their senators before the vote to urge them to oppose the measure. According to firsthand reports, senatorial offices used intimidation, falsehoods, and mockery against citizens who called to voice their opinion. One claimed that callers would be fined 500 pesos for the phone call. Another claimed that the call was tracked and that the caller would be investigated by the police.

A Spanish-language video containing audio recordings of several calls was posted on the Protege La Vida page this afternoon:

Advocates for abortion legalization claim that the law will reduce high rates of maternal mortality, despite recent studies that show that countries prohibiting or severely restricting abortion, like Ireland and Chile, enjoy among the lowest maternal mortality rates. The new law even permits late-term abortions in certain medical cases, despite the recent International Symposium on Maternal Health’s finding that abortion is never medically necessary.

Opposition leader Senator Jorge Larranaga promises that his National Party will overturn the law after the 2015 presidential elections. ”Experience from other countries shows that legalization doesn’t resolve the problem,” Larranaga said during debate today, adding that abortion is a matter of basic human rights. “We will repeal this law.”

Live Action on Facebook
  • uruguayan 38

    This article is totally misleading and unbiased. Polls in Uruguay such as the one of CIFRA (a well-known and trusted Uruguayan poll company) have shown systematically that most Uruguayans think that the women’s right to health should be a primary concern and therefore support de-criminalizing abortion. The “intimidation” mentioned in the article (which is not even explained) simple did not exist . Uruguay is well-know for its democratic stability and legal system that grants the citizen’s freedom. We Uruguayans are proud of that and will not accept that people advocating for one or the other cause will put that in question. I understand that the author might be outraged but lying is not an acceptable way to deal with such sensitive issues.

    • http://twitter.com/dreadhelm Josh Craddock

      CIFRA’s poll only surveyed 800 people. The survey I referenced in my article is the largest survey on abortion in Uruguayan history and reached 3.5% of the national population–an insanely large sample size as far as surveys go.

      The intimidation (such as threatening fines or police action) was reported firsthand by callers to their Senate offices. Many of these calls were recorded. The one shown in the article exhibits the mockery directed toward concerned pro-life Uruguayans.

      There is a massive grassroots movement of pro-life Uruguayans who are against legalizing abortion. This is demonstrated by the thousands of calls to legislators and the rapid growth of the Protege La Vida page I referenced.

      Accusations of lying are unmerited and inappropriate.

  • Pingback: Possible good news for the unborn children of Uruguay?